The Forgotten Cure Chapters 1-4
d’Herelle first discovered bacteriophages when he observed plaques in the bacterial cultures from sick locusts he had grown, however he was unable to reproduce this, and it was unpursued for a few years. He was able to eventually study bacteriophages when he was studying an outbreak of dysentery in the troops at Maisons-Laffitte. While studying the bacteria the clear spots or plaques once again appeared and d’Herelle was able to observe and study the cause. When he noticed that the plaques only appeared in the samples from patients that were recovering he started to study the possibility of using these bacteriophages as they would be called to help with the recovery of patients with dysentery and other bacterial infections or in other words phage therapy. d’Herelle’s discovery was aided not only by his initial observation when he was studying locusts, but also by the ability to study many samples brought by outbreaks of dysentery often found in troops at the time.
One of the major characteristics that lead to d’Herelle becoming a successful scientist were probably the fact that he was not afraid of criticism, his dedication to his discovery, and that he was outspoken when it came to his discovery. His discovery while accepted by some was challenged by others. If he had been afraid of controversy or had not been as outspoken and willing to defend his discovery when it was challenged, then then the study of phage therapy may not have gone as far or maybe not anywhere at all. He was also very dedicated to the idea of phage therapy and he performed many studies on the effectiveness of this procedure. If he had left more of this to other scientist, it’s likely that it would not have gone as far as the success of his studies are what help spark the interest of other scientists to also perform experiments on phage therapy.
One major way that politics influenced was in Russia. Lenin’s push for public health helped Eliava establish a lab where he could further study bacteriophages and phage therapy. d’Herelle on several occasions also traveled there to assist Eliava which further pushed the study of phage therapy. However, the politics in Russia also halted Eliava’s studies in Russia as well as his and d’Herells’ cooperation when those who had been educated before the revolution including Eliava began being arrested and executed by Stalin. I this way specifically using Russia as an example of how politics helped push the research of phage therapy as well as halted it in Russia.
I major reason was that the results of phage therapy were often inconclusive. This was because scientists often did not have a control to compare their results against. This cause them to be unable to tell the reason behind patients’ recovery especially when more than one procedure was used. One example that was mentioned was that patients with boils would often have them lacerated and cleaned before the phage were added. Without a control it was impossible for anyone to tell whether a patient’s recovery was the laceration of the boils, the phage therapy, or both. A major reason that control groups were neglected was because the scientists often did not wish to deny patients something that could help them of save their lives. This mindset is definitely understandable, however this prevented the successfulness of phage therapy from being confirmed and it was eventually abandoned.